Cycling: Tubeless vs. Tubes — a nine months experience

in #hive-1777452 years ago

Heeeyho Readers! Swinging by to spice up the cycling community!


Last year, I wrote a tutorial on a DIY tubeless system for bicycles. We know the pain in the behind it is to change a flat tire during a ride, let alone when we are training on thorny trails. Still, despite the benefits of running tubeless wheels, some of us — me included — hesitated to try it out. Let's discuss based on my nine-month experience with tubeless.

Check this post for the DIY tubeless: Cycling: No more flat tires with DIY tubeless

1.jpg

Fixing tubeless wheels


The picture above explains last weekend's training. Cross country trail packed with pointy rocks and below-ideal tire pressure. The result is a pinched tire. Wouldn't be a problem had I checked the sealant the day before {Do'h}. We managed to continue training after adding a tube and re-inflating the tire. Lesson learned.

I decided to check the system after this experience. After all, nine months of use without problems is way beyond the recommended time. (Yes, I added extra sealant during these months.)

Rear wheel evaluation after nine months

The 3M silver tape held incredibly well. It's so firm in place and intact that I see no need to replace. Keep in mind that the 3M silver tape costs 5x less (southern Brazil) than the more commonly used Gorilla tape. Other tubeless rim tapes will do the same, just varying the cost.

20230417_121820.jpg

3M silver tape after nine monthss


The tire and sealant bonded as expected. There were no issues in nine months. All punctures sealed fast (mostly thorns) and the tires held air without significant loss of pressure throughout the days. The only issue is cleaning the tire for maintenance.

20230417_154323.jpg

Dried sealant

20230417_154255.jpg

Cleaning


Regular tubeless maintenance involves removing old sealant from the tire. It's tedious and requires patience. All this gunk adds weight if not removed. The ideal is cleaning every three months. Other than that, just adding sealant from time to time will keep you running for months.

20230417_163025.jpg

Clean tire


The above is how much sealant I removed from the rear tire — nine months of adding sealant whenever it dried up. I re-assembled the rim, added fresh sealant and inflated. Done. The process took a good junk of the afternoon, but the wheel is ready to roll again.

Tubeless vs. Tubes

I'm not going back to tubes anytime soon based on my experience. Nine months of extreme use without issues is plenty of time to test the reliability. Zero flat tires and stopping to change tubes. Just don't forget to add sealant.

Let me break into sections.

Reliability 4/5

Not a five because tubeless is not perfect. Any bigger tear in the tire will force you to add a tube. However, I'm a Cross Country racer that's not afraid to tackle technical rock gardens, which were not enough to cause me any problems (it depends on your tire, I'm using 2.35 Maxxis Ikon front/rear).

Maintenance 2/5

You gotta look after your wheel set. Adding sealant whenever it dries is part of the hassle. Checking/cleaning the system every three months or so is quite time consuming. Running for nine months was a bit too much, since all that extra sealant adds unwanted weight. Tubes eliminate the above-mentioned tasks. Checking the pressure is the only maintenance with tubes; or fixing whenever it's pinched.

Cost 3/5

Definitely more expensive than buying a tube, even if opting for my DIY solution. There's the cost of maintenance for those who rely on bicycle shops to service the bicycle. I consider a three because there are DIY options or super expensive ones. Up to you.

Final Thoughts

I recommend going tubeless for everyone that uses the bicycle on a daily basis (athletes/commuters). The reliability surpasses the time spent patching tubes; and the maintenance becomes part of the regular bicycle maintenance.

Tubeless might not be that beneficial for those who use the bicycle once a week or less — mainly because the sealant will dry up —, not justifying the cost.

If you are an avid cyclist, try it out and take your conclusions. I'm curious to see.

Peace.


Did you know that I have a book out? Check this!

Access Link: https://www.amazon.com/dp/6500272773?

Sem Título-2.jpg


If you enjoyed this post consider leaving your upvote for a hot coffee.

Find me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/mrprofessor_

~Love ya all,


Disclaimer: The author of this post is a convict broke backpacker, who has travelled more than 10.000 km hitchhiking and more than 5.000 km cycling. Following him may cause severe problems of wanderlust and inquietud. You've been warned.


I'm Arthur. I blog about Adventure Stories, Brazil, Travel, Camping, & Life Experiences.

Follow me to stay tuned for more craziness and tips.

Sort:  

Thanks for the write up and explanations. I have often wonder about tubeless set up. It is good to confirm as I don't ride my road or mountain that often I am probably best off sticking with my tubes
!LUV
!LOL
!ALIVE

Hey, thanks for the comment! Yeah, I don't think it justifies the cost of sealant, unless you are dealing with flat tires often. I ride nearly everyday and was dealing with flats every week when I used tubes (pain in the butt).

What is Victorias Secret?
High prices.

Credit: reddit
@mrprofessor, I sent you an $LOLZ on behalf of @new.things

(9/10)

PLAY & EARN $DOOM

@mrprofessor, @new.things(1/10) sent you LUV. | tools | discord | community | HiveWiki | NFT | <>< daily

Made with by crrdlx

@mrprofessor! You Are Alive so I just staked 0.1 $ALIVE to your account on behalf of @new.things. (1/10)

The tip has been paid for by the We Are Alive Tribe through the earnings on @alive.chat, feel free to swing by our daily chat any time you want.

Well, for cross-country racing it totally makes sense. For my 3 month and 4000 km trip, using mostly less traveled roads (incl. the bottle strewn "crystal shoulder"), with the occasional forest trail or logging road, and still having only 4 flats in total (two of them on my last day!), I'm not sure if I would have done it tubeless. Those few roadside tube-changing sessions, annoying as they may have been at the time, remain an integral part of an overall positive experience. But maybe for more adventurous trips, like bike-packing on the Baja California divide, I can see going tubeless as a viable option.

You are lucky! I had several punctures in my trip; had two within 30 minutes. The worst part was not even fixing, but dealing with a wet and muddy bicycle 🤢

The only problem in longer trips is carrying sealant, although you should be fine for at least two or three months.

Aw man, that sucks! I know the wet and muddy situation very well, and I am thankful I never had to fix a flat in those conditions. But if I did... hahaha, I would most certainly switch to tubeless right away!

untitled.gif

Messy!! It destroyed my chain/cassette in 2 months and a half


Upvoted by the Cycling Community
image.png

Thanks for the informative blog!
I'm a road cyclist and not using tubeless.
I once received the tip to buy Continental Grand Prix outer tires.
They have an extra protection in them that prevents from punctures.
I've been riding between 4000 and 6000 kilometers a year for the past four years and only had one punctured tire.
When you cycle throught glass the glass literally breaks because of the protection layer.
They are a bit expensive, but I think they have saved me from several punctures already!

image.png

Hey! One puncture in four years is impressive, not to say lucky haha
You might have great roads near you. Here we get a lot of those small wires that come off truck tires; that's the nightmare for local road cyclists. For us mountain bikers the thorns.

I wouldn't go tubeless in your case. Totally not worth it if reinforced tires are doing the trick.